Saturday, February 15, 2014

The Most Important Question In The Universe



          To say that the universe is massive is not an understatement of science or sight. You have mass, your car has mass, and the Earth has mass, yet this is nothing compared to the mass of other planets in our solar system and especially our Sun. Looking through a telescope to see distant galaxies that have around 100 billion stars each instills both a trifling feeling of personal purpose and a unique awe reserved only for those realizations that have moved man to myth and legend for millennia.

          In science the universe has a measurable, knowable amount of mass that can be calculated based on a number of theories, some of the most famous, relativity for example, coming from Albert Einstein. The trouble though is that the amount of stuff in the universe that can be seen only accounts for less than 5% of all the mass in the universe. It is remarkable that this amount of mass goes unseen, which is why it is called ‘dark’, but what is truly astounding is that science does not know what it is. That is to say in our high-tech ‘knowledge is power’ world we cannot explain 95% of what is out there. Roughly 27% of this is called dark matter, a scientifically proven phenomenon that gives galaxies their signature flat shape, and numerous other universal characteristics, but has eluded cosmological attempts to be captured and identified. Fascinating, still normal and dark matter only account for a relatively small amount, what about the other 70% of the mass of the universe?

          The question of dark energy is one of the most substantially essential and basic unanswered question in the Universe. Because it deals with the expansion of the universe dark energy not only speaks to where we have come from, but also what the future may hold for our universe (though we certainly won't be around to see it). Its relatively recent discovery enthralled scientist and has torn a rift between what we thought we knew and what is actually happening.

          From his Mount Wilson perch beyond the city lights of Los Angeles in the 1920’s rockstar astronomer Edwin Hubble (namesake for the space telescope) not only demonstrated that the night sky was made up of other galaxies and not just stars from the Milky Way, but that the universe was expanding. Just as the sound of an object deepens as the waves begin to elongate when the object moves away, so too happens with the light of a distant galaxy; except instead of becoming deeper as sound is perceived these elongated waves appear red, the longer wavelength of visible light. That is why this observation was called red shift. Even though we’re not in the center of the universe everything is red shifting away, which makes sense if you think of  a balloon that is being inflated. As the balloon expands it grows out in its entirety in all directions from that point of genesis, therefore giving any point the appearance that any other point is moving away.
           
          This view dominated the discipline for nearly seventy long years until scientists began to ask some important questions based on the nature of the mass of the universe with regards to this point of genesis, or the so called big bang. If there is too much mass in the universe wouldn’t galaxies start to attract each other and slow down like a cowboy lassoing a calf, maybe even to the point where the expansion of the universe might reverse as celestial bodies get hurled together because of their competing gravity? Or if there wasn’t enough mass we could just expand forever at the same speed. Turns out it wasn’t until 1998 when cosmologists realized that neither of these were the case.

Tycho's Supernova Remnant In X-Ray
          The breakthrough came when studying type 1a supernovae. Great distances are difficult to measure in the universe due to the inconsistencies of light emissions; however these supernovae were known to give off a very specific measurable amount of light. Using these exploded stars as a ruler cosmologist could figure out how far away they were and the extent of their red shift. These galaxies and stars were much more distant than anything that had been surveyed before and scientists discovered that they were about 25% fainter than what they should have been, based on previous models. Because the light that was observed was from farther away that meant that it was also from farther back in time (a couple billion years or so), in the sense that longer distances that light has traveled necessarily represents an older period of the universe. These observations led scientists to assert that the best explanation fitting the evidence was that the universe wasn’t just expanding, but actually speeding up. This research was being done concurrently and independently by two different teams, the success of which was revered by the Nobel Prize.

          The amount of matter needed to accelerate the universe, and space itself, gives scientists the 68% number, yet we still don’t know what it is. There are about three main theories that attempt to shed some light on the perplexing inconsistencies that give rise to dark energy. It could be a property of space to the extent that the vacuum of space either has its own energy density or a sort of quantum foam where particles spontaneously come in and out of existence, in a similar fashion to how foam in a beer will form then pop at will. Dark energy could also be some kind of new field or fluid, not unlike the recent discovery of the Higgs Boson at CERN, but it is so small and weak that our instruments cannot detect it. Or finally that Einstein’s theory of relativity, and the basis for nearly all of what we think we know, is simply wrong and another theory is needed.


          The consequence of the questions surrounding dark energy should not be lost on us. Whatever it turns out to be the answer will fundamentally shift some of the most basic tenants of our universe. It will impact the fundamental way in which science is conducted and how we go about situating our knowledge in truth. Questions like where the universe came from, what forces have given it shape, what is the nature of the interaction of the celestial bodies, and what does this imply for the future of our known universe all depend on a greater understanding of dark energy. And that is why dark energy is the single most important question in our universe.

Deeper: The Dark Energy Survey is a scientific conglomerate that is currently using a highly sophisticated digital camera fixed to a Chilean telescope to peer back deep into the past of our universe to seek answers for dark energy. NASA has a great article about the dark side of the universe and one of the members of the original teams to discover dark energy, Alex Filippenko of UC Berkeley, gives a great, if not sometimes confusing, talk about the acceleration of the universe. Those curious about astronomy, including myself and my five year old nephew, can explore NASA's enduring educational contribution in the Astronomy Picture of the Day